Why Retailers Need to Rethink Their Seasonal Hiring Playbook in the Age of AI
Every fall, retailers race to staff their stores for the holiday shopping season. For years, the seasonal hiring playbook focused on filling shifts for the holiday rush as fast as possible.
In today’s hiring environment, speed alone is no longer enough. Retailers now need a playbook that balances hiring velocity with candidate quality, uses artificial intelligence and automation to handle the volume, and keeps people in the decisions that matter.
The candidate pool is getting thinner. According to ICIMS Insights, application volume across high-volume industries fell 18 percent below the September 2025 baseline in September, and applicants per opening dropped to their lowest point of the year. New research also found that 42 percent of high-volume and frontline employers saw recruiting needs come in higher than forecast. Even under that pressure, 62 percent say selecting the highest-quality candidate is their top priority, and 61 percent say quality of hire carries the most weight with leadership.
The signals of quality are also getting harder to trust. Only about a quarter of retail and restaurant employers are very confident a resume reflects real skills. Seventy percent of high-volume and frontline employers encounter candidates who intentionally misrepresent themselves, and half believe AI-generated resumes are already in their applicant pool. A seasonal associate handles cash, inventory and customers from day one, so candidate authenticity has become a seasonal hiring risk retailers have to plan for.
Here's how retailers can move fast and hire with confidence.
1. Let AI take on seasonal hiring volume.
Seventy-five percent of high-volume and frontline employers say AI has reduced their recruiting team's workload, with screening delivering the most value. Seasonal hiring moves at a pace that calls for technology built specifically for high volume. That means a conversational application candidates can finish by text or chat in minutes, AI that scores applications so the best fits rise to the top, and self-scheduling that books interviews automatically. One global retailer that moved to purpose-built high-volume hiring technology cut time-to-hire from 20 days to 11 days.
2. Put skills ahead of the resume.
High-volume and frontline employers ranked skills-based hiring as their top recruiting priority for the next 12 months to 18 months. In retail, that can mean short questions about availability, customer scenarios, and register or stockroom experience. A skills lens also helps with placement. A candidate who applied for the sales floor may be a better fit for fulfillment or merchandising.
3. Keep people in the decisions that matter.
AI adds speed, and it also adds responsibility. Forty-one percent of frontline employers report a greater need for oversight and validation since adopting AI, and a third have noticed growing candidate skepticism. The strongest seasonal programs let AI handle the volume while store managers make the final call, reviewing scored candidates from their phones between shifts. Employers also rank compliance, risk and fraud detection as their top AI investment priority.
Measuring Seasonal Hiring Success
Retailers that balance speed with quality see it in the numbers. Employers using purpose-built, high-volume hiring technology have reduced time-to-fill by as much as 75 percent and cut time spent on manual tasks by up to 90 percent. Because candidates are screened for skills and reviewed by the managers who will lead them, retailers gain confidence in who shows up for the first shift. Strong seasonal associates also become the pipeline for next year and for permanent roles.
Speed will always matter in seasonal retail hiring. The retailers that pair it with better signals, smarter automation, and human judgment will build the most confident teams on the sales floor this holiday season.
Lisa Fiondella is senior vice president, high volume hiring, ICIMS, the intelligent hiring platform.
Related story: Holiday Hiring is a Major Compliance Risk. Here’s How to Get it Right
- Categories:
- Hiring
Lisa Fiondella, Senior Vice President, High Volume Hiring and AI, ICIMS
Lisa Fiondella is SVP of High Volume Hiring and AI at ICIMS, bringing extensive background in product development, AI, data, analytics and business operations. Previously, she led Data & Analytics at ICE Mortgage Technology, where she oversaw the expansion of mortgage data through a new data platform. She also served as Chief Data Officer at Finastra and held leadership roles at Experian, Reed Elsevier, Fiserv and Equifax. Additionally, Lisa founded and led an analytics company focused on customer lifecycle solutions for B2B sales and marketing firms.





